A Thriller Does What a Mask Does


At my first Shadows of the Fathers event, in front of a full room at Watermark Books in Wichita, I asked a simple question: why do you like thrillers?
The answers were all over the map. But I'd bet some version of the same thing sits underneath every one of them. We like being scared when some part of us knows we're safe. A haunted house, a costume, a thriller novel. It's all the same trick. You try on something intense and a little dangerous, then you take it off when you're done.
A thriller does what a mask does.
I didn't summarize Shadows of the Fathers that night. I told a story about the story instead: three choices people in the book have to make. I didn't tell anyone what those characters chose. I asked the room what they would choose. Here's that conversation, for anyone who couldn't be there.
The mask and what's behind it
The psychologist Carl Jung wrote about the persona and the shadow. The persona is the mask, the polished version of yourself you show the world. The shadow is everything behind it: the traits and urges that don't fit the story you tell about yourself, so you push them out of sight. Jung's point wasn't that the shadow is evil. It's just unlived. It's the self you didn't let yourself become.
That idea shaped every major character in the book. Villains get interesting when they let their shadow drive. Heroes get interesting the moment you realize theirs is just better hidden.
Hunter Long, my main character, can't stand a coworker who gets praised for doing less. He says he doesn't care about recognition. It burns him anyway. That's how a shadow works. What bothers us most in someone else is often the thing we don't want to admit about ourselves.
I'll confess one of mine. I don't fully think of myself as an author yet, even with a published book in my hands. That gap has a name, imposter syndrome, and it has nothing to do with whether the accomplishment is real. I wrote the book. It's out in the world. The feeling just hasn't caught up to the fact yet. If that sounds familiar in any part of your life, you're in good company.
So here's the first question I put to the room: what did you inherit? A habit, a saying, a fear, a way of arguing. We all carry something we didn't pick.
Three questions the book won't answer for you
If we all have a shadow, then the hard choices aren't really about good versus evil. They're about which version of yourself you let drive when it matters. Here are three of those choices. No spoilers. I won't tell you what anyone decides.
Loyalty
Hunter has a friend in Mexico named Raul who helped him through something terrible years ago. Hunter trusts him completely. Raul also has a mother, a sister, and kids he's responsible for. At some point in this book, protecting that family and staying loyal to that friendship stop being the same thing.
Then there's Victor, a double agent with family on both sides. His loyalty lives at two addresses.
What do you do when protecting your family means letting down a friend who trusted you with his life?
Surviving versus becoming
The villain of the book is Santiago, twenty-four years old, cartel royalty, his father in a U.S. prison. Santi doesn't think he's the bad guy. He thinks he's a son finishing what his father started. He doesn't even call it violence. He calls it peace.
He runs the cartel like a modern company, with drones, encrypted comms and social media. And he wraps it all in devotion to Santa Muerte, the skeletal folk saint, because faith makes the work feel sacred instead of criminal. Every fall, Mexico honors its dead with candlelit ofrendas, marigolds and sugar skulls for Día de los Muertos. Santa Muerte is something different: a figure venerated year-round, by many people for many reasons. In Santi's hands, she becomes one more mask. A skull or a saint, whichever does the job that day.
Nobody in that world thinks of themselves as evil. People choose sides to survive, to protect their families, because the alternative got worse first. That isn't an excuse. It's the truth I wanted the book to sit in, instead of handing you a cartoon villain to hate from a safe distance.
Where's the line between surviving something and becoming the thing you were trying to survive?
Pleasing people versus doing what you want
Hunter was raised by his grandfather, a legendary CIA operative, and trained for that world since he was a kid. His grandfather wanted something else for him: a linguist, a diplomat, a lawyer. Hunter joined the CIA anyway, and he calls it defiance. It isn't, really. He spent his whole life being shaped for that world. Choosing it is its own kind of obedience dressed up as rebellion.
Bianca Cruz, the cartel heiress engaged to Santi, is the sharper version. She's made the public face of her late father's organization. Nobody asked her if she wanted it. Now she has to decide how much of that role is actually hers.
Are you doing something right now because it's expected of you, not because you'd have chosen it on your own?
Why I wrote it this way
Some of you want me to tell you how at least one of these turns out. That itch is exactly what I wanted the book to give you.
I made a rule while writing it. I don't judge my characters on the page. I show you how they see themselves, put you in their heads, and let you decide what you think of them. The book will entertain you. It will also hand you people who are sure they're doing the right thing, and leave the verdict to you.
I ended the night with one last question, and I'll leave it with you too:
Who in your life cast a shadow over you, and what did they teach you about carrying your own?
Every person in this book is someone's child, carrying something they didn't choose, wearing a mask they didn't always pick. That's not just fiction. That's most of us, most days. I wrote Shadows of the Fathers because I wanted a thriller that would scare you a little, surprise you a lot, and leave you wondering what you would do in the same situations.
Thank you to Watermark Books for hosting, and to everyone who came out that night.
If you haven't read it yet, now you know what you're walking into. Find every format, plus signed bookplate editions from my partner bookstores, at crowleyclark.com/shadowsofthefathers.



